Navigating Sales Competition with ModelRisk: A Laptop Retailer’s Journey

https://www.gleeym.com/?p=6271
https://www.gleeym.com/?p=6271

In the rapidly evolving world of electronics retail, predicting future sales is never straightforward—especially when there’s a high chance of new competitors entering the market. For one laptop retailer, the challenge was clear: project sales growth over the next 100 months while preparing for the potential impact of new competitors. By leveraging ModelRisk, a robust risk analysis tool by Vose Software, the retailer was able to simulate multiple competitive scenarios and gain invaluable insights into future sales trajectories.

Using ModelRisk, the I created a trend chart for sales. The chart enabled the retailer to anticipate both the expected growth in sales and potential dips if a competitor were to enter the market. Let’s delve into how they structured their analysis and what they discovered.

Setting the Scene: Inputs and Assumptions

Currently, the laptop retailer enjoys steady monthly sales of about 1,000 units. However, with an 80% chance of a competitor entering the market at some point within the 100-month forecast period, they knew they had to prepare for the possible impact on their sales volume.

Here are the key parameters they used in ModelRisk to set up the simulation:

  1. Probability of Competitor Entry: 80% – Given the high likelihood of new competition, the retailer modeled potential sales loss if a competitor entered the market.

  2. Competitor Entry Time: 38 months – This was the estimated point at which the competitor might enter the market, though simulations allowed for variation in this timing to explore different competitive entry points.

  3. Expected Fraction of Sales Lost Due to Competition: Modeled with VoseUniform(0.1, 0.3) – This parameter enabled the model to simulate a range of sales reductions, from 10% to 30%, representing mild to severe competition.

  4. Current Sales per Month: 1,000 units – Serving as the baseline sales value before any growth or competitive effects were applied.

  5. Expected Growth per Month: Modeled with VoseUniform(1.3, 6) – Reflecting the potential monthly growth rate, this parameter allowed for variability in demand, ranging from 1.3 to 6 units per month.

Using these inputs, the retailer was able to simulate potential sales growth paths while accounting for competitive pressure, resulting in a clearer understanding of possible outcomes.

Modeling Sales Growth and Competitor Impact

The retailer structured the model to capture two critical components of future sales:

  1. Organic Sales Growth: Using VoseUniform(1.3, 6), ModelRisk generated monthly growth rates, capturing both conservative and optimistic growth scenarios. This established a baseline for sales growth in a competitor-free environment.

  2. Competitor Impact: If a competitor entered the market (as determined by the 80% probability and Competitor Entry Flag), ModelRisk applied a sales reduction based on VoseUniform(0.1, 0.3). This represented the possible decline in sales due to increased competition, allowing the retailer to assess the potential range of impacts on sales volume

The Trend Chart: Visualizing Sales Projections

After running the Monte Carlo simulation, ModelRisk produced a trend chart for sales that illustrated various potential sales trajectories over the 100-month period.

In the trend chart, the red dashed line represents the median sales trajectory, showing the expected path if the competitor enters at the anticipated time (around month 38) and causes a temporary dip in sales. The shaded blue areas represent the confidence intervals for projected sales:

  • Light blue band: Represents the range of sales outcomes within the middle 50% of simulations, indicating the scenarios that are more likely.
  • Dark blue band: Encompasses a broader range of possible outcomes, including both optimistic and conservative scenarios.
Sales Trend Chart by gleeym.com as result of Monte Carlo Simulation.

Key Insights from the Trend Chart

The trend chart revealed some valuable insights for the retailer:

  1. Impact of Competitor Entry: Around month 38, the red median line and shaded regions show a noticeable dip, representing the anticipated loss in sales if a competitor enters. This impact is short-lived, with sales growth resuming in the following months.

  2. Sales Growth Despite Competition: Even with the competitor’s entry, sales are expected to continue growing after an initial decline. This upward trend highlights the resilience of organic growth, although the presence of competition tempers it slightly.

  3. Range of Potential Outcomes: The chart’s shaded regions illustrate the wide range of possible sales figures, from the low end (bottom of the dark blue band) to high growth scenarios (top of the dark blue band). This view allows the retailer to understand both best- and worst-case sales scenarios, preparing them for various market conditions.

Strategic Takeaways

Armed with insights from the trend chart, the laptop retailer can make more informed decisions, such as:

  • Enhancing Early Market Share: By focusing on increasing sales early in the 100-month period, they can build a buffer to mitigate potential losses when a competitor enters.
  • Targeted Marketing Efforts: Knowing the likely time of competitor entry (around month 38), the retailer can plan promotions or loyalty programs to retain customers.
  • Risk Management: With the range of potential outcomes shown in the trend chart, the retailer can create contingency plans to handle both conservative and optimistic scenarios.

Reference

Quantitative Risk Analysis

GleeyM Offer services to identify risks and perform Quantitative Schedule Risk Analysis (QSRA) and Quantitative Cost Risk Analysis (QCRA) for mega complex projects!

Workshop Facilitation

GleeYM Offers Workshop Facilitation to help you to make the best decisions for your business and projects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *